Please rate the student’s paper on the variables listed below, where 1 is superior, 2 is acceptable, and 3 is unacceptable.
___________ A research question or hypothesis was clearly stated.
___________ A methodology section was included in the paper.
___________ A discussion section which described the findings and placed them
in the context of current literature was included.
___________ The paper was well-written and included no grammatical errors.
___________ A statistical analysis of the data was done where appropriate.
Overall, I would rate this paper:
_________
__________ Acceptable
__________ Unacceptable
Please rate the student’s presentation on the variables listed below, where 1 is superior, 2 is acceptable, and 3 is unacceptable.
______________ A general audience could understand the subject of this
presentation.
_____________ Helpful visuals were included.
_____________ The student was able to answer questions from the audience.
_____________ The student’s appearance was professional.
_____________ The student made eye contact with the audience and was very
self-confident in his/her delivery.
______________ The presentation flowed well.
Overall, I would rate this presentation:
__________
__________ Acceptable
__________ Unacceptable
If you have additional comments on either the paper
or the presentation, please share them here.
For instance, if an important factor or issue is not captured by these
questions, please mention it here.
Based on this evaluation and your
experience reading other Honors theses, would you support this student’s work
for “Pass with Distinction?” YES
NO